PDA

View Full Version : Tillmar et al. 147 Somali's Y STR to Y DNA



Almagest
07-04-2017, 02:29 PM
http://www.fsigeneticssup.com/article/S1875-1768(09)00079-1/pdf

E-V32 110/147 (74.8%)
T-M70 11/147 (7.5%)
E-Z827 11/147 (7.5%) of which 9/11 (82.0%) are E-M81
J-M267 4/147 (2.7%)
J-M172 2/147 (1.4%)
E-V38 2/147 (1.4%)
E-V22 1/147 (0.7%)
L-M20 1/147 (0.7%)
E-M35*(xM78) 1/147 (0.7%)

Unknown 4/147 Ht No. 27,29,54,57. If anyone knows these STR's, especially DYS19 = 12, let me know.

Squad
07-13-2017, 03:44 AM
You made some mistakes though. There are 7 E-M81 samples, 5 J1-M267, 1 J2-M172 sample and 5 E-M35 (xE-M81, E-V32) (some could be E-M78 (xE-V32) and E-M123). Ht no 27 is most likely one of these E-M35 cases, ht no 29 is E2-M75 and 54/57 are both E-V32 with DYS19 mutated to 12.

Almagest
07-16-2017, 01:13 AM
You made some mistakes though. There are 7 E-M81 samples, 5 J1-M267, 1 J2-M172 sample and 5 E-M35 (xE-M81, E-V32) (some could be E-M78 (xE-V32) and E-M123). Ht no 27 is most likely one of these E-M35 cases, ht no 29 is E2-M75 and 54/57 are both E-V32 with DYS19 mutated to 12.

These are the notes I made;

No. 25,39,45,59,60,61 E-Z827
No. 7,37,49 J-M267
No. 51,65 J-M172

Squad
07-27-2017, 09:53 PM
Only no.25 and 39 are E-M81. 39, 59 and 60 are some kind of E-M78 or E-Z830. Interesting that you pointed no.61 out as I didnt notice it. I can tell you with 100% accuracy that it does not belong to any E-M35 or even E as a whole. It is in fact very strange and the closest thing it looks like is some kind of Q. I'm sure it belongs in K somewhere...

no.51 is T, not J.

The other J-M267 you missed is no.43 from a known yemeni cluster.

Almagest
08-05-2017, 01:32 AM
Only no.25 and 39 are E-M81.
I would add 45 as well. Generally E-M35 haplotype with DYS391=9 is an easy E-M81. 39, 59 and 60 have DYS391 mutated to 10, but overall a very similar haplotype make me lean 60-40 in favour of M81 rather than Z830


Interesting that you pointed no.61 out as I didnt notice it. I can tell you with 100% accuracy that it does not belong to any E-M35 or even E as a whole. It is in fact very strange and the closest thing it looks like is some kind of Q. I'm sure it belongs in K somewhere...
Yes, it looks closest to a strange T actually.


no.51 is T, not J.
I agree


The other J-M267 you missed is no.43 from a known yemeni cluster.
Source

Squad
09-10-2017, 03:38 PM
My bad, I wantd to say only 25 and 45 are E-M81, not 39. 39, 59 and 60 are definitely not E-M81, it's not just because of DYS391 being 10, it's that with DYS389 = 13-30, DYS439 = 11 or 12 and DYS385 being too high. I can tell you it is IMPOSSIBLE that these samples are E-M81. As for 43, the yemeni subgroup is known and you had it mistaken for E-M35 beacause of its high DYS385a = 17, but that is a known recLOH event...